Page 1 of 1

Should the Mega spell activation text be displayed

PostPosted: Wed Sep 20, 2017 2:01 pm
by Grythandril
Whenever a spell is cast whether is succeeds or fails the text is displayed in the battle log afterwards

Same applies to talismans when activated appears in the battle log afterwards

But the activation of the Megaspell activation text is displayed in the battle log to all players

Surely the activation text should be absent to give the game more of a surprise element factor?

Any thoughts?

Re: Should the Mega spell activation text be displayed

PostPosted: Wed Sep 20, 2017 3:52 pm
by anjovi
It would increase the hilarity of losing 1 to a vengeance spell :lol:
Otherwise, it doesn't seem to be very consequential to me either way. The only thing i can think of is bluffing the "Oh shite! I don't have enough mana to cast this mega spell! I just need a bit more time to burn cards so that i for sure have a real cast!"

but the same could be said if a megaspell just popped out without the indicator.

I guess it just acts as more of a means to add a theatrical effect. I can't remember ever activating a mega spell and not casting it.
Although..........if there was a spell that allowed players to suck up another player's mana...that would be a whole other story ;)

Re: Should the Mega spell activation text be displayed

PostPosted: Wed Sep 20, 2017 4:08 pm
by Mazy
There was a period when the mega-spell activation was kept secret, in retrospect I think it might be better the way it is now. For continuity you want the log to display all types of activations.

If you do activate it early (many turns before intending to cast it) you are effectively announcing the activation (you could use this as a way of sending out a warning)..

..Rarely do players actually activate it on the turn before they intend to cast it though (unless they are playing the AI), generally players will activate it on the turn they intend to cast it, the risk of losing the pre-activated mega-spell card to an MA is risky. Plus if you activate it but don't cast it you wont draw a new spell card that turn (if you have spells to come).

So adding the activation to the log did introduce some different tactics with regard to when you choose to activate it.

Re: Should the Mega spell activation text be displayed

PostPosted: Wed Sep 20, 2017 5:02 pm
by MattyRasker
Yes, the mega spell activation text should be displayed as it does now.

Re: Should the Mega spell activation text be displayed

PostPosted: Wed Sep 20, 2017 7:36 pm
by SpiteAndMalice
Mazy wrote:
If you do activate it early (many turns before intending to cast it) you are effectively announcing the activation (you could use this as a way of sending out a warning)..



+1 - It can be activated tactically at present, I quite like that too. + As Anjovi says it can increase tension within a game if you know that one has been activated.

Re: Should the Mega spell activation text be displayed

PostPosted: Fri Sep 22, 2017 2:43 pm
by Grythandril
it nice to hear a different perspective and sometime I just see one side without realising the other side.

thanks for the feedback

:D

Re: Should the Mega spell activation text be displayed

PostPosted: Fri Sep 22, 2017 2:46 pm
by MattyRasker
Nice to see a thread not descending into discussion chaos for a change you mean :D